How an Exeter bowls club claimed Gift Aid for the first time in 17 years
Hilary Penrose became treasurer of Exe Vale Bowls Club, a 72-member lawn bowls club on the edge of Exeter, in January 2026. The club had been registered with HMRC as a community amateur sports club since 2009. In 17 years it had never made a Gift Aid claim.
Illustrative story: Hilary, Exe Vale Bowls Club and the figures below are fictional. The HMRC rules are real and linked from GOV.UK.
TL;DR
Exe Vale needed £4,400 to re-level a rink. Its appeal raised £3,240 from 38 members, 31 of whom signed Gift Aid declarations, which made £690 claimable. The open day took £1,126 in buckets and contactless gifts of £30 or less, worth £281.50 under the small donations scheme. HMRC paid £971.50 in 22 days. The committee also dropped a plan to add a Gift Aid box to the £95 sub, which would have meant claiming £1,710 that a CASC cannot claim.
Hilary Penrose
Treasurer · Exe Vale Bowls Club, Exeter
Where the club started
Hilary spent 30 years as a practice manager at a GP surgery and retired in 2024. She took the treasurer's job because nobody else would.
- 72 members paying a £95 annual sub, most of them over 60.
- Two outdoor rinks, a pavilion bar and a summer open day that drew about 200 people.
- A cash book, a shoebox of receipts and a members' WhatsApp group where donations were announced and then forgotten.
- CASC status since 2009, registered by a treasurer who had since moved to Cornwall.
What made her look at Gift Aid?
In February the greenkeeper reported that the north rink had sunk at one corner. The quote to re-level it and replace the ditch boards was £4,400, and the club had £2,100 in reserves it could not spend on one rink.
Members had given before. Hilary found £1,850 of member donations in the cash book between 2022 and 2025, for a new mower and the pavilion roof. Not one came with a declaration. Ordinary Gift Aid can be claimed up to four years after the period the gift was received in, but only with the donor's declaration, so there was nothing to go back for.
"We'd had the status for seventeen years and nobody had used it. I worked out we'd left about four hundred and sixty pounds on the table from the mower and the roof alone, and that was just the years I could find."
Why not just put Gift Aid on the subs?
That was the first suggestion at the March committee meeting. Add a Gift Aid box to the renewal form, and 72 subs at £95 would be worth £1,710 a year.
Hilary said no, and brought the page to show them. HMRC's guidance says membership payments to a CASC never qualify, because members get personal use of the club's facilities. A claim on subs would be wrong in full, and a penalty would also shut the club out of the small donations scheme for that year and the next.
What did she change?
- She made the appeal a separate thing. The green appeal ran in April and May 2026, after the subs were paid, with its own post in the club's Bitir channel and a line that said giving was entirely optional.
- She asked for the declaration at the moment of giving. Every member who said they would give got the declaration form with the bank details on the same page. Paper forms came back to her at the club; none of them went through the chat, because they carry home addresses.
- She recorded every gift the same day. Each donation went into the Payment widget with a note: "green appeal, declared" or "green appeal, no declaration".
- She put a contactless reader on the open day. It was set to £5, £10 and £20 buttons next to the buckets, and its own report was printed and kept, as the small donations scheme requires.
- She claimed both in the same tax year. The appeal and the 13 June open day both fell in 2026 to 27, so one Charities Online claim on 2 July covered both.
What changed in the numbers?
The declared gifts came to £2,760, worth £690. The open day added £1,126 in buckets and contactless, worth £281.50. With £3,240 of appeal money, £1,126 from the open day and £971.50 from HMRC, the rink was paid for in August and £937.50 went back into reserves.
Two of the four non-taxpayers asked her afterwards whether they had done something wrong. They had not. Hilary had taken their gifts happily and simply left them off the claim.
"The claim itself was one evening with the spreadsheet. The work was getting thirty-one bits of paper back from people who'd rather be on the green, and making sure every one of them matched a line on the bank statement."
What Hilary does in Bitir
- The Payment widget to record every donation with a note saying whether a declaration is held.
- Member claims with receipts, so members who give by bank transfer attach their confirmation and she checks it before confirming.
- A CSV export of the tax year's payments, checked line by line against the bank before the claim goes in.
- A Treasurer role that gives her the payments rights without making her a full admin.
- Dated tasks in her name for the claim, the small donations deadline and the annual check that every declaration is filed.
- A pinned post explaining in four lines what Gift Aid is and why subs do not count.
What she would tell another club
- Find out whether you are a CASC or a charity before you plan anything. Yours might have been one for years.
- Keep donations and subs apart, on different forms and at different times of year.
- Ask for the declaration when someone says yes, not a month later.
- Claim only what you can trace from the bank to a form.
- Put the open day and the appeal in the same tax year if you can.
What's next
The committee has agreed an annual pavilion fund with a standing declaration for anyone who wants to give monthly. Eleven members have signed up so far. Hilary has also asked the bar committee to keep the contactless reader on the counter for the Christmas raffle night, with a clear sign that the raffle tickets themselves do not count.
Questions we're asked about this story
Why could the club not claim Gift Aid on subs?
Exe Vale is a community amateur sports club, and HMRC says membership payments to a CASC never qualify for Gift Aid because members get personal use of the club's facilities. A tick-box on the renewal form would have produced a claim of about £1,710 that HMRC could reject and penalise.
Could the club claim on donations from earlier years?
Only where it held valid declarations, and it held none. Ordinary Gift Aid can be claimed up to four years after the end of the period a donation was received in, but without a declaration from the donor there is nothing to claim on, so £1,850 of earlier member gifts stayed unclaimed.
How did the open day earn a top-up without forms?
Through the Gift Aid Small Donations Scheme, which pays 25% on cash and contactless donations of £30 or less with no declaration. It only works because the club also claimed ordinary Gift Aid in the same tax year, and the £1,126 collected was well under both the £8,000 cap and ten times the club's declared donations.
Is Exe Vale Bowls Club real?
No. Hilary Penrose, Exe Vale Bowls Club and the figures in this story are fictional and written to illustrate the guidance. The HMRC rules come from published GOV.UK guidance, which is linked in the article.
Keep every gift traceable
Record donations with a note, confirm members' transfers against their receipts, and export the tax year in one file.
Set Up Your Club